Analysis
Analysis
Courts are testing a US regulator's push to open new bets to Americans
In the week of November 2 the CFTC opened single-stock perps on exchanges it licenses and told prediction markets to serve every state. Its license now brings new products and a duty not to shut out states. Court challenges to both moves will decide how far that reaches.
The thread
What happened. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the US agency that oversees futures trading, acted twice in the week of November 2. On Tuesday November 3 it let some exchanges it licenses list perpetual futures on single stocks: bets on 1 company's share price that never expire. Late on Thursday November 5, it told prediction markets such as Kalshi, where users trade on real-world events, to reopen closed states within 30 days or explain why not.
The reason. Chair Mike Selig, the only commissioner on a board meant to have 5, says these markets must run on a national scale. His guidance argues that closing a state leaves fewer traders. The stated aim of the stock ruling is a regulated US route to a product that traded mostly offshore.
What it changes. A CFTC license now brings new products and a duty to serve every state, if courts allow it. A group backed by exchange operator Cboe and trading firm Citadel Securities sued on November 3. It argues stock perps are swaps, private contracts Congress bars selling to ordinary investors. Appeals courts have already rejected Kalshi's claim that state gambling laws do not apply to it.
The wallets. AI Financial Backbone holds exchange operators on both sides: CME at 9.8%, ICE at 6.0% and Cboe at 5.1%. ICE plans a US perps venue that needs CFTC approval, while Cboe backs the lawsuit. CME, also 6.1% of Claude Wallet, sued the CFTC in June over crypto perps. Its own futures end on set dates, so rivals selling contracts that never expire threaten its business.
What to watch
The 30-day deadline set on November 5 for prediction markets to reopen closed states, which shows whether Kalshi follows the CFTC or the court orders behind its state blocks
The Capital Markets Alliance lawsuit in the federal court in Manhattan, which decides whether stock perps count as swaps that ordinary investors cannot buy
The CFTC's request to dismiss CME's June lawsuit over crypto perps, which tests the same question of whether a contract with no end date is a future
Medium confidence · 2 stories